نظام نوآوری و بوم‌سازگان نوآوری: بازخوانی مبانی فلسفی دو رویکرد در مطالعات نوآوری

نوع مقاله : مقاله پژوهشی

نویسندگان

1 دانشجوی دکتری سیاست‌گذاری علم و فناوری، گروه مدیریت تکنولوژی و نوآوری، دانشکده مدیریت صنعتی و فناوری، دانشکدگان مدیریت، دانشگاه تهران

2 استاد گروه مدیریت فناوری اطلاعات، دانشکده مدیریت و اقتصاد، دانشگاه تربیت مدرس، تهران

10.22034/rahyaft.2026.12343.1684

چکیده

تحولات چند دهه اخیر در مطالعات نوآوری، به گسترش چارچوب‌های تحلیلی مختلف برای فهم فرایندها، کنشگران و روابط مؤثر بر شکل‌گیری نوآوری انجامیده است. در این میان، «نظام نوآوری» و «بوم‌سازگان نوآوری» از چارچوب‌های مهم در مطالعات نوآوری به شمار می‌روند. با وجود گستردگی ادبیات مربوط به این دو رویکرد، مفروضات بنیادین و جهت‌گیری‌های فلسفی نهفته در نحوه صورت‌بندی آن‌ها کمتر به‌طور نظام‌مند مورد توجه قرار گرفته است. پژوهش حاضر با هدف بازسازی و مقایسه تحلیلی گرایش‌های فلسفی غالب در ادبیات نظام نوآوری و بوم‌سازگان نوآوری انجام شده است. این پژوهش از نوع نظری و با جهت‌گیری تفسیرگرایانه است و بر فرایندی سه‌مرحله‌ای شامل مرور هدفمند ادبیات، تحلیل مفهومی و بازسازی فلسفی استوار است. در این فرایند، ویژگی‌ها و مفاهیم محوری دو رویکرد شناسایی و پس از تحلیل و پالایش مفهومی، در قالب «خردمایه‌های فلسفی» صورت‌بندی و با استفاده از چارچوب بوریل و مورگان مورد مقایسه قرار گرفتند. یافته‌های پژوهش نشان می‌دهد که اگرچه دو رویکرد در تأکید بر تعامل، یادگیری و ارتباط میان کنشگران دارای اشتراکات مهمی هستند، در نحوه برجسته‌سازی و صورت‌بندی مفاهیمی مانند نظم، هماهنگی، پیش‌بینی‌پذیری، انعطاف‌پذیری، هم‌تکاملی و خلق مشترک ارزش، گرایش‌های فلسفی متفاوتی را بازتاب می‌دهند. بر این اساس، نظام نوآوری و بوم‌سازگان نوآوری را می‌توان نه به‌عنوان دو ابرانگاره(پارادایم) فلسفی مستقل یا دو رویکرد ذاتاً متعارض، بلکه به‌عنوان دو سنخ آرمانی تحلیلی با جهت‌گیری‌های غالب متفاوت در نظر گرفت. این بازسازی تحلیلی نشان می‌دهد که تفاوت میان دو رویکرد صرفاً به تعاریف، عناصر یا سازوکارهای آن‌ها محدود نیست، بلکه به نحوه صورت‌بندی واقعیت نوآوری، روابط میان کنشگران و فرایند شکل‌گیری نظم نوآورانه نیز مربوط می‌شود. از این منظر، توجه به مبانی فلسفی و خردمایه‌های نهفته در چارچوب‌های مطالعات نوآوری می‌تواند به خودآگاهی مفهومی و استفاده سنجیده‌تر از این چارچوب‌ها در تحلیل و سیاست‌گذاری نوآوری کمک کند.

کلیدواژه‌ها

موضوعات


عنوان مقاله [English]

Innovation System and Innovation Ecosystem: Rereading the Philosophical Foundations of Two Approaches in Innovation Studies

نویسندگان [English]

  • Saman Roohbakhshan 1
  • Sepehr Ghazinoory 2
1 PhD Student in Science and Technology Policy, Department of Technology and Innovation Management, Faculty of Industrial and Technology Management, College of Management, University of Tehran, Tehran
2 Professor, Department of Information Technology Management, Faculty of Management and Economics, Tarbiat Modares University, Tehran
چکیده [English]

Recent developments in innovation studies have led to the proliferation of analytical frameworks for understanding the processes, actors, institutions, and relationships involved in innovation. Innovation systems and innovation ecosystems are influential approaches that emphasize innovation’s relational character while foregrounding different concepts and conditions. Although the literature on these approaches has expanded considerably, the assumptions and philosophical orientations implicit in their conceptualization have received comparatively limited systematic attention. This study aims to analytically reconstruct and compare the dominant philosophical orientations that can be inferred from the literature on innovation systems and innovation ecosystems. Rather than assigning fixed philosophical positions to either approach, it examines how recurring theoretical emphases can be interpreted in relation to broader assumptions about social reality, knowledge, human agency, and methods of inquiry.
The study is theoretical and interpretive in nature and follows a three-stage process comprising a targeted literature review, conceptual analysis, and philosophical reconstruction. First, influential contributions to the innovation systems literature, including work by Freeman, Lundvall, Nelson, and Edquist, and to the innovation ecosystems literature, including work by Moore, Adner, Oh and colleagues, Granstrand and Holgersson, and Russell and Smorodinskaya, were reviewed to identify recurring concepts and theoretical emphases. Second, the identified concepts and features were examined, clarified, and grouped according to their analytical meaning. Third, the resulting patterns were interpreted through the framework developed by Burrell and Morgan, which distinguishes perspectives in terms of assumptions concerning ontology, epistemology, human nature, and methodology. The framework serves as an interpretive reference for organizing and comparing reconstructed orientations, rather than as a rigid classification scheme into which each approach or author must be placed.
The philosophical rationales discussed here are intermediate analytical constructs inferred from recurring features in the literature. They should not be understood as explicit philosophical declarations made by the scholars reviewed, or as definitive evidence that an approach belongs to a single philosophical school. The analysis does not presume a direct, causal, or one-to-one correspondence between individual features and particular dimensions of the framework; it interprets patterns of emphasis while recognizing the diversity of both literatures.
The findings indicate that the two approaches share important common ground. Both understand innovation as a relational process and emphasize interaction, learning, interdependence, and the roles of multiple actors. Their distinction is better understood in terms of relative emphasis than as a separation between exclusive sets of concepts. In the innovation systems literature, recurring emphases include the configuration of actors and institutions, systemic interdependence, collective learning, institutional arrangements, and coordination among system components. In the innovation ecosystems literature, recurring emphases include heterogeneous actors, evolving interdependencies, interaction across organizational boundaries, adaptation, co-evolution, uncertainty, and the ongoing creation and capture of value.
Philosophically, these differences can be considered in relation to order and change, coordination and adaptation, predictability and uncertainty, and the relationship between structure and agency. Systems-oriented literature offers concepts for examining interdependent components and the institutional conditions under which innovation takes place. Ecosystem-oriented literature more explicitly foregrounds the fluidity of relationships, the heterogeneity of participants, and the development of interaction through continuing mutual adjustment. These tendencies are not exclusive attributes: system-oriented analyses can address change, uncertainty, and agency, while ecosystem-oriented analyses can recognize structure, coordination, and stability. The findings therefore do not support a simple opposition in which each approach represents a fixed philosophical position. Rather, innovation systems and innovation ecosystems can be treated as analytical ideal types characterized by different dominant, but not exclusive, orientations.
This distinction matters because analytical frameworks do not merely provide alternative labels for innovation. They influence which aspects of a phenomenon become visible, how problems are formulated, which actors and relationships receive attention, and what kinds of intervention appear relevant. A framework that foregrounds institutions, systemic relationships, and coordination may direct attention toward institutional capacities, linkages, collective learning, and the alignment of system components. A framework emphasizing evolving interdependencies, heterogeneity, adaptation, and co-evolution may encourage analysis of changing actor configurations, emerging relationships, mutual adjustment, and value creation and capture. These differences shape research questions and may help policymakers reflect on the assumptions embedded in their analytical choices.
The policy relevance of this argument is not that one approach should replace the other or that either is inherently superior. Instead, greater awareness of their conceptual and philosophical emphases can support more considered use of each framework in relation to the problem at hand. Innovation challenges differ in institutional settings, actor configurations, uncertainty, and patterns of interdependence. Clarifying a framework’s assumptions can help researchers and policymakers identify what it illuminates and what it leaves less visible when conducting policy analysis or designing interventions.
The study is limited by its conceptual and interpretive design rather than an empirical test of the orientations identified. Its findings depend on the selected literature and on analytical judgments about which recurring concepts imply broader philosophical assumptions. The comparison should therefore be read as a structured interpretation of dominant tendencies, not as a definitive taxonomy of the fields or their scholars. Future research could examine how these reconstructed orientations appear in empirical studies, policy documents, and practical applications of innovation frameworks. It could also extend the comparison to entrepreneurial and knowledge ecosystems, transformative innovation systems, and mission-oriented innovation policy.
The study’s value lies in bringing philosophical reflection into a comparative analysis of two influential approaches through a structured process of conceptual reconstruction. By distinguishing explicit philosophical statements from interpretations inferred from recurring theoretical emphases, it makes the basis of comparison more transparent and open to scrutiny. The analysis suggests that the distinction between innovation systems and innovation ecosystems concerns not only their definitions, elements, and mechanisms, but also how they frame the reality of innovation, relationships among actors, and the emergence and transformation of order. Treating them as analytical ideal types with different dominant orientations enables comparison of their explanatory priorities without assuming that they are independent philosophical paradigms, mutually exclusive alternatives, or hierarchically ordered approaches. Greater awareness of these rationales can contribute to conceptual clarity in innovation studies and to more reflective, context-sensitive use of analytical frameworks in innovation analysis and policymaking

کلیدواژه‌ها [English]

  • Innovation
  • innovation system
  • innovation ecosystems
  • innovation philosophy
  • philosophical foundations of innovation
  • innovation policymaking